If you’re planning a bathroom renovation, chances are you’ve had the “shower or a bath” discussion. Whether you’re building a new bathroom or simply considering an upgrade, choosing between the two (or deciding to include both) can be a tricky decision. Both options have their own set of perks and challenges, and what works for one person may not be the best fit for another. 

To help you make an informed choice, we’re looking at the pros and cons of each, as well as giving you a few top tips on what to consider when making your choice. 

Should I install a bath in my bathroom? 

There’s no denying the charm of a long, relaxing bath. Baths are a sanctuary for relaxation. The warm water, the ability to immerse yourself fully, and the time to read a book or listen to music offer an experience that showers can’t quite replicate. For families with young children, a bathtub can also make bath time a much simpler task. It’s a safe space to wash little ones who may not be ready for the independence of a shower. 

A large bathtub, for example, can turn bath time into a fun family ritual. Parents can relax knowing the kids are happily playing in the water, while they enjoy a break themselves. It’s an easy way to make the most of a busy evening, especially if you’re trying to juggle multiple children who need help getting clean. 

The main downside to having a bathtub is that it requires more space. If you’re working with a smaller bathroom, a large tub might take up too much room. Plus, baths generally use more water than showers, which can be a concern for those who are trying to conserve water or keep household bills in check. If you tend to indulge in long soaks, the water usage adds up over time. 

Should I install a shower in my bathroom? 

Showers have become the go-to choice for many, and it’s easy to see why. They are fast and convenient, especially for busy mornings when time is tight. A quick 10-minute shower uses much less water than filling up a bathtub, so for people with hectic schedules, this efficiency is a major advantage. 

A shower-only setup might be ideal for a family on the go, think about those busy school mornings when everyone is rushing to get out the door. A shower can provide the perfect, no-fuss solution for getting clean quickly. 

They’re also a great choice for individuals with mobility challenges or those planning to stay in their home long term. Walk-in showers make it easier to get in and out without worrying about the high edge of a bathtub.  

If you’re thinking about long-term comfort and ease of use, a shower can be adapted with features like grab bars, handheld showerheads, or built-in seating. For older family members or anyone with physical limitations, the accessibility factor alone can make a shower the more practical option. 

The biggest downside of a shower is that it’s simply not as relaxing as a bath. It’s hard to create the same peaceful atmosphere in a shower, especially if you’re used to unwinding in a bathtub. They may also not be as convenient for families with young children (or mucky pets)! 

If you would prefer a shower (or your space is better suited for a shower), and you still want to replicate the relaxation of a bath, why not consider a steam shower? We install these too, and many of our customers find they still offer a spa like experience, combined with all the convenience of a shower! 

Making the right choice for your home 

So how do you decide between a bath or a shower? The answer depends on several factors, including your available space, your lifestyle, and your long-term needs. 

Room size  

If you have a spacious bathroom and love the idea of relaxing in a tub, a bathtub might be a great choice. However, if you have limited space, fitting in a large tub may not be feasible. A shower takes up less room and can be installed in a much smaller space. Alternatively, if you have a large bathroom and space for both, a combination of both, like a bathtub with a showerhead over it, could provide the flexibility you need.  

Lifestyle and family needs 

Your lifestyle plays a big role in the decision. For families with young children, a bathtub can make bath time easier and safer. Kids often feel more comfortable in a bathtub, and parents find it less stressful to supervise bath time. A large tub makes bath time more fun and gives parents the chance to relax as they watch the kids play. 

But as kids grow older, they often outgrow the need for a bathtub and prefer showers instead. If your kids are at an age where they prefer to shower independently, you might find a larger shower to be a better investment. 

Future-proofing your bathroom 

It’s important to think about how your needs might change over time. If you plan to stay in your home for the long haul, consider how your future lifestyle might influence your bathroom choice. Showers are often easier to use as people age, especially if you incorporate accessible features like a low entry or a built-in seat. 

For example, if you’re planning to stay in your home for many years, you might want to choose a design that accommodates potential mobility issues. A walk-in shower could be a smart investment for future comfort. 

Need some extra help deciding whether a bath or shower is right for you? Talk to our friendly team, we’d love to help with your bathroom renovation.